Eis het ontslag van Jozias van Aartsen
Gast |
/ #8063 Should we call ISIS 'evil'?2014-08-22 20:17By James Dawes
August 22, 2014 -- Updated 1231 GMT (2031 HKT)
Editor's note: James Dawes, director of the Program in Human Rights at Macalester College in St. Paul, Minnesota, is the author of "Evil Men" (Harvard University Press). The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of the author. (CNN) -- When most people look at ISIS, they see the incarnation of evil. Among its many horrific acts, the Islamic militant group beheaded American journalist James Foley and posted the video this week in retaliation for U.S. airstrikes in Iraq. The Pope typically protests violence, but he implied that he supports the use of military force to combat ISIS. Even al Qaeda says ISIS is too violent. Across the political spectrum, public officials and pundits have characterized them as "savages," a "cancer" and the "face of evil." Is ISIS evil? The problem with that question is that the answer is as easy as it is useless. Yes, ISIS is evil and must be stopped. Saying so over and over again could very well make it harder to stop them. There is only one good reason to denounce a group as evil -- because you plan to injure them, and calling them evil makes it psychologically easier to do so. "Evil" is the most powerful word we have to prepare ourselves to kill other people comfortably. The flip side is that "evil" is also a word that stops us from thinking. There is no point in trying to understand evil because it is, in the most typical phrasing, "inhuman," "senseless" or "beyond comprehension." It is a fool's quest to analyze the local realities and strategic imperatives of unthinking savages. There is something almost offensive about trying to understand such evil. National Review's Jonah Goldberg tried to shame those who are trying to think seriously about ISIS. In a recent tweet, he mocked the attempt to understand ISIS in its social and political context, suggesting that we should focus instead on one fact: "They're evil. They do obviously evil things for evil ends." The fact is, there are few things more dangerous now than allowing ourselves to think that way. To resist ISIS and, perhaps more importantly, the larger social forces it represents, the U.S. will need more than a collective psychological readiness to injure, and more than bombs. The Wall Street Journal editorialized that this evil ideology will only be stopped when "enough of its fanatics have been killed." But if we've learned anything as a nation since our "shock and awe" campaign in Iraq, it is this: While invasions and bombing can be effective in the short term, they are not durable solutions to terror-based violence. Even if U.S. military force could effectively destroy ISIS, there will be similar groups waiting in the wings. If we are to have any hope of preventing the spread of extremist ideologies, we must do more than bomb the believers. We must understand them. We must be willing to continue thinking. How is ISIS able to achieve the support it needs? What drives people into its ranks? What social pressures and needs, what political and regional vacuums, make it possible for a group like this to thrive? We can choose to answer these questions in two ways. We can say they are evil people doing evil things for evil ends. Or we can do the hard work of understanding the context that made them, so that we can create a context that unmakes them. We can analyze the ways its violent tactics are effective for its purposes given the local power dynamics, so that we can also better understand its weak spots. And we can ask how it is that normal men -- men who were not born evil -- get turned into monsters, so that we can work to change the structures that produce terrorists over the long term instead of locking ourselves into an endlessly repeated, short-term policy of "killing fanatics" until they are gone. Trying to understand something isn't the same as trying to justify or excuse it. That's a basic mistake, and a costly one. As Jane Harman, president of the Woodrow International Center for Scholars, recently wrote: "We can't counter radical narratives if we don't understand the motives of the radicalized." Nonetheless, trying to understand evil is an offense. It is an offense to everything we hold dear, because understanding -- that is, true and effective understanding -- must bring us close to the other, must help us see the world through their eyes. That is a painful, offensive process, and that is exactly what we must do.
http://edition.cnn.com/2014/08/22/opinion/dawes-isis-evil/index.html?hpt=hp_c2 |
|
Steun KEES van DAAIBOOI BEACH CURACAO
Open brief aan de Belgische regering - Leg de lat hoger: stop de blokkade, stop de genocide
Gort over de grens moet blijven.
Zwembad het Baafje Heiloo moet open blijven!
Wij willen een eerlijke boer.inn.enlandbouw!
Behoud Losloopgebieden voor Honden op de Utrechtse Heuvelrug, in Austerlitz, en Zeist
Kortsnuiten Blijven Bestaan
De St. Victorkerk behouden voor ontmoetingen.
Bescherm minderjarige vluchtelingen tegen het nieuwe asielbeleid!
Castratie-/sterilisatieplicht huiskatten Nederland
Red Nederland: Heropen de Gaswinning!
EINDE CORONA CRISIS: Overheid sta behandeling van COVID-19 met HCQ en zink en / of Ivermectine toe!
Voor een realistische snelheid van 90km/u op de Houtlaan in Wijnegem!
Respecteer de euthanasiewet
Geen Noodopvang / AZC op het Hocrasterrein te Bussum
Gelijkwaardigherstel mag niet stoppen!
Wij eisen het intrekken van de huidige vergunningen van de Fourwinds Policedog center in Geffen!
Is er iets dat u wilt veranderen?
Verandering vindt niet plaats door te zwijgen. De auteur van deze petitie stond op en ondernam actie. Zult u hetzelfde doen? Start een sociale beweging door een petitie aan te maken.
Start uw eigen petitieAndere petities waarin u mogelijk geïnteresseerd bent
Hou IJsbaan DE PISTE Kortrijk open !
812 Gemaakt: 2025-07-05
Behoud de NS JongerenDagkaart
2572 Gemaakt: 2025-06-24
Bezwaar Windturbines Stad Kortrijk
240 Gemaakt: 2025-07-03
Gort over de grens moet blijven.
5603 Gemaakt: 2025-06-16
🆘 Red voetbalvereniging Batavia’90 – Laat de gemeente niet wegkijken!
715 Gemaakt: 2025-06-28
Steun Poptempel De Kuip
9378 Gemaakt: 2024-10-12
Stop het visieloze RUP voor Schildestrand
302 Gemaakt: 2025-06-25
NEEN, geen zonnepanelen op "de Pit" in Nieuwkapelle!
572 Gemaakt: 2022-05-17
Geen windmolens op de Grashoek
89 Gemaakt: 2025-07-03
Pak ons buitenzwembad niet af!
1829 Gemaakt: 2025-06-02
NEEN aan de afbraak van de NEKKERHAL in MECHELEN
5283 Gemaakt: 2025-06-15
Betonstop Maria-ter-heide/ Brasschaat
272 Gemaakt: 2025-06-17
Tegen het rookverbod op terassen
1282 Gemaakt: 2025-02-02
Stop de container MSNU9636101!
44 Gemaakt: 2025-07-04
Laat de johannesschool bestaan
464 Gemaakt: 2025-06-16
Nee tegen een moskee
205 Gemaakt: 2025-06-20
Breng buslijn 461 en de sneltram terug op koers – genoeg omwegen, tijd voor oplossingen!
73 Gemaakt: 2025-06-23
Widjai bezorger post nl
194 Gemaakt: 2025-06-25
Petitie voor vangnet ouders van ernstig zieke en terminale kinderen
65781 Gemaakt: 2023-01-17
❌ Petitie tegen de locatie van de nieuwe brandweerkazerne in Nieuwpoort
220 Gemaakt: 2025-06-18